STATEMENT: Tiger Farms: A ticket to Extinction
International Tiger Coalition: STATEMENT
EMBARGOED FOR 11 PM EST, MAY 8, 2009
ABC's 20/20 promotes flawed economics and false conservation value, says International Tiger Coalition
WASHINGTON DC - The International Tiger Coalition (ITC), an international group of organizations committed to ending tiger trade, rejects the false and deeply flawed argument that tigers bred on industrialized farms can save wild tigers as presented on ABC's 20/20 tonight.
Tiger farms were established and are managed primarily for commercial trade, not conservation, driven by profit from the sales of tiger-bone wine and skins. At present, all commercial trade in tigers and their products is illegal. But as long as there are tiger farms that promise a future reopening of tiger trade, the ban cannot be effective.
Since initiating a domestic ban on tiger trade in 1993, the Chinese government has removed tiger bone as an ingredient in the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) pharmacopeia and invested in the development of effective alternative medicines and public awareness campaigns. It has been very effective in protecting wild tigers by stopping the previously legal market, reducing demand and allowing some fragile tiger populations to stabilize, such as the Siberian tiger in the Russian Far East.
A contingent of business owners with financial interest in large-scale tiger farms and their supporters are now pushing China to rescind the ban. Permitting even a limited trade in farmed tigers within China will undermine decades of conservation efforts across the range of the tiger by reigniting a market demand that has nearly been extinguished and increase poaching of wild tigers.
Poaching will always be too cost-competitive an option to ignore: consider the price of a bullet, trap or poison to kill a wild tiger against an estimated US$4,000 to US$10,000 to raise a farmed tiger to maturity. Wild-sourced products are also consistently perceived to be superior by consumers, a situation that has resulted in wild Asiatic black bears being poached despite the saturation of the Chinese market with bear bile from farmed bears.
Finally, the notion that tigers bred on a farm can be reintroduced to the wild, thus contributing to the survival of wild populations, has no factual basis. Farmed tigers are likely to be too genetically and behaviorally compromised to be released into the wild.
Farming tigers for trade will only hasten the irreplaceable loss of a species on the brink. With improved enforcement, existing bans can wipe out tiger trade before tiger trade wipes out wild tigers.
"It is inconceivable that profit and the bottom line was the only lens through which 20/20 approached the issue of tiger farming," said Grace Gabriel, Asia Regional Director of IFAW and ITC member, who was interviewed by the show. "Every player in that trade chain is criminally responsible for the depletion of tigers in the wild, from poachers to smugglers to traders and to those who promote tiger trade: investors and owners of tiger farms."
"Unfortunately, 20/20 focused on sensational and unproven free-market theories applied to tiger farming instead of presenting a balanced report on the inherent risks to the tiger?s very survival in the wild," said Judy Mills of Conservation International and Moderator of the ITC, who was interviewed on the show. "All our science and studies indicate that opening tiger trade and encouraging tiger farms is bad news for wild tigers and by extension, for people and the planet."
NOTE TO EDITORS:
B-roll (TRT: 2.06, NATSOT):
http://www.divshare.com/download/7307598-cf7
High-resolution images:
http://www.savethetigerfund.org/Content/NavigationMenu2/News/MediaKits/TigerFarmMediaKit/default.htm
FOR MORE INFORMATION:
International Tiger Coalition:
Trishna GURUNG, WWF E: [email protected] T: 202-203-8863
Conservation International:
Judy MILLS E: [email protected] T: 202-674-4588
International Fund for Animal Welfare:
Grace GABRIEL E: [email protected] T: 508-496-4471
Stockpiles of Dead Tigers Should be Destroyed, Experts Urge China
Tiger Experts to Tour China Tiger Farms, Participate in Review of Trade Ban
World Governments Reject Tiger Farming and Trade; A Victory for Wild Tigers, Coalition Says
Massive Photo Mosaic of Tiger to be Revealed at CITES; Delegates Urged to End Tiger Trade
Study: Viable Tiger Populations, Tiger Trade Incompatible
China Must Back Statements on Tiger Trade Ban With Concrete Steps to Phase Out Tiger Farms
Conservationists Await Concrete Steps For Phasing Out China's Tiger Farms
Groups Release TV Spot Urging Nations To Reject Reopening of China Tiger Trade
Conservationists Welcome U.S. Commitment To Oppose Reopening of China Tiger Trade
Tiger Experts to Testify Before Congress Against Lifting of China's Tiger Trade Ban
Tiger Experts Dismayed That Tiger Meat on Chinese Menu
Conservationists Call on China to Support Law Over Tiger Farms